Home > The West Music Blog > Three Widespread Misconceptions About the Suzuki Method
West Music Blog

The West Music Blog


Subscribe
Three Widespread Misconceptions About the Suzuki Method
By Amanda Hazelett
10/27/2010 3:30:00 PM

Originally written by Suzuki instructor Ronda Cole and author Katie Lansdale

1. ‘Suzuki students don’t read music’ was justified in the early years. Japanese Suzuki students began violin at three, and began reading around five to six, upon reaching Book 4. The first American teachers lowered the starting age of students, but not as low as three, and failed to re-evaluate when to start reading. Critics were quicker to complain than appreciate the younger development of talent. Fortunately, the adjustment between age and reading in America was corrected years ago; the old complaints still echo occasionally.

2. ‘They play like robots!’ Robotic playing can be heard by students of any teacher, using any approach. Listening to recordings is not to blame: students listen to create their ‘inner song,’ not to copy interpretations. The level of musicality taught and expected from students depends entirely upon the teacher’s standards and persistence.

3. An enormous, hurtful misunderstanding is that at some point students should ‘finish’ with Suzuki and move on to a ‘real’ teacher. Since Suzuki teaching embodies an educational philosophy, it does not ever ‘end.’ If the work between a student and teacher is fruitful, it should continue. The differences between Suzuki and other approaches are most evident in the beginning. As a Suzuki student advances, components of ‘traditional’ lessons multiply: scales, rhythm studies, conducting, études, theory, and reading. My students also report on a recording or concert they heard, play a tune they worked out by ear, and recite a memorized poem. My advanced students play major repertory in lessons, but still benefit from group class, with solo opportunities and an extended group repertory.




Tags: Suzuki Method, Suzuki Violin Method, Violin Method, Instrument Method
Categories: Band & Orchestra
Bookmark and Share

Comments:

No Comments have been submitted.

   
 
Write your own comment
 
  Your name (required):  
   
  Your email address (required):  
     
  Your website address (optional):  
   
  Submit a Picture No larger than 250kb (optional):  
   
  Submit a video via URL (optional):  
   
  Your comments (required):  
   
   
 
Text From Image:
 
   
 
Categories
Mariachi (11)
Live Sound, Recording & Software (4)
Music Advocacy (52)
Music Education (92)
piano (6)
Band & Orchestra (82)
Classroom Furniture & Equipment (12)
Company Culture (71)
Conservatory (345)
Contests (12)
Pianos, Digital Pianos & Keyboards (23)
Drums & Percussion (25)
Extraordinary Associate of the Month (46)
Guitars & Folk (35)
Kids & Movement (26)
Live Sound & DJ (8)
Music Therapy (55)
Music, Books & Resources (62)
Orff (15)
Press Releases (17)
Recorders (16)
Recording & Software (8)
West Music Cedar Falls (66)
West Music Coralville (145)
West Music Decorah (3)
West Music Marion (110)
West Music Piano Gallery (58)
West Music Quad Cities (77)
West Music Dubuque (1)
 
Recent Posts
First Time Baritone/Euphonium Players
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
First Time Violin Players
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
Music on the March: The Joy of Sousa
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
Des Moines July 2017 Musician of the Month: Channing Rooda
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
Cedar Rapids July 2017 Muisician of the Month: Christine Newlin
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
Cedar Rapids July 2017 Musician of the Month: Sophia Spinner
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
Coralville July 2017 Musician of the Month: Jayce Norpel
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
Cedar Rapids July 2017 Teacher Feature: Les Ohlhauser
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
Des Moines July 2017 Teacher Feature: Mark Willie
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
Des Moines July 2017 Teacher Feature: Esther Lim
  Comments: 0
  Rating: 0 / 0
 
McAfee SECURE sites help keep you safe from identity theft, credit card fraud, spyware, spam, viruses and online scams